Technologies
mmmcluhan/response
McLuhan would have viewed today’s technologies as a massive cultural shock due to their pervasive influence and constant presence in daily life. As for mechanical, technological advancements, Ford intended for the Model T to be, “a machine rested on the supposition of mechanical skill in its owner [where] simplicity was part of reliability” (Mahoney 4). The leap from the Ford Model T to the modern Fords/vehicles, which possess complex transmissions & systems that mostly require professional mechanics, would likely have blown his mind. Since much of the Human Struggle is to find meaning, society is constantly deteriorated by popularized tensions, “between forces of closure (or domination) and openness (or popularity)” (Fiske 5). He would probably argue that modern technologies, particularly social media apps, contribute to heightened anxiety and reflect the growing trends of ADHD & anxiety in younger generations that foster shorter attention spans. The rapid spread of information and propaganda through news channels would worry him, as media today is like a "lightning bolt" of anxiety which delivers constant, overwhelming stimulation. However, McLuhan would likely acknowledge the benefits of these technologies as well, particularly in how they increase access to knowledge and connect people around the world… Though he’d remain cautious about the drastically negative side effects of such fast, fragmented communication.
“…the people are unlikely to choose any commodity that serves only the economic and ideological interests of the dominant” (Fiske 5).
Media
These examples fit McLuhan’s definitions of media since they expand and intensify his ideas in the context of modern technology. While today’s media may not be the same technical form as, say, print or the telegraph, it amplifies McLuhan’s original concepts. For instance, social media acts as an extension of our senses, specifically the sense of touch and sight, by allowing us to engage with virtual communities and "feel" connected to people through likes, comments, and notifications. McLuhan would have observed how these platforms suck users in, providing instant, dopamine-driven feedback loops, which satisfy briefly but leave an ongoing hunger for more validation. It reinforces his discussion hat media "extends" human faculties but also causes a shift in how we process reality. Furthermore, the anxiety that comes with social media, such as the pressure to constantly check notifications or the emotional impact of public validation or invalidation, fits McLuhan’s idea that new media creates tension. The constant desire for more likes or attention mirrors his view that media culture promotes a sense of unfulfilled longing, where there’s always an urge to reach for the next moment of validation, never truly satisfied. The cycle reflects McLuhan’s thesis that media doesn’t just deliver messages, it profoundly shapes the way we think, feel, and interact.
Inventory
Insecurity
“Perhaps at this point you have had enough and leave. Or maybe you stay. You feed the change machine a five dollar bill and stuff your pocket with more quarters. You challenge someone to two player. Maybe you win. Maybe you lose. Maybe it is getting late, and you realize that you have neglected your algebra homework again” (Kocurek 10).
“The last quarter burned, and you hit the machine hard enough that it stings your hand. You feel foolish, but no one notices. They are too busy watching some kid down the row who has been playing steady for an hour on one quarter” (Kocurek 10). Kocurek’s portrayal of early video game effects would feed into McLuhan’s decision to add insecurity to his inventory of effects, particularly the sense of inadequacy bestowed by constant comparison on social media. Users compare their bodies, achievements, and lifestyles to others which leads to feelings of unfulfillment and anxiety. The pressure to project an idealized image and seek validation fuels self-doubt, creating a toxic cycle of comparison with influencers, celebrities, and even peers.
Addiction
McLuhan would also note the addictive nature of today’s media. The constant need for validation through likes and comments creates a cycle of dependency, where users seek more immediate gratification. This addiction disrupts real-world engagement, as people become fixated on their online personas and external approval, and perpetuates a never-ending loop of consumption that never truly satisfies.
“They suspect the ear; they don't trust it. In general we feel more secure when things are visible, when we can "see for ourselves." We admonish children, for instance, to "believe only half of what they see, and nothing of what they hear." All kinds of "shorthand" systems of notation have been developed to help us see what we hear” (McLuhan 117).
Design
If McLuhan designed The Medium is the Massage as a website, he’d use a fragmented layout with brief, interconnected descriptions to cater to short attention spans. Visuals would shift abruptly, with hyperlinks showing the ease of accessing diverse media and how impactful that is. He’d include a collage-style gallery illustrating everyday media influences, like celebrity culture and technology. Text would combine bold phrases and subscript notes to emphasize impact/connotation. Interactive elements would allow users to collaborate and share their thoughts that would prove McLuhan’s point on how media shapes human interaction and perception.
The Medium
The use of personal computers and technology to deliver McLuhan’s message would add an ironic layer, as he’s using the very medium he critiques to spread his ideas. However, it would also amplify his message, as the audience would engage with it through the same technologies, reflecting their everyday use and habits. The vastness of the web could bury his message unless it’s amplified by influential figures, professors, or viral social media creators, which emphasizes the complexities of how media spreads and stands out in a crowded digital landscape.
Made on mmm